I ordered this shirt a size up because I wanted it to feel loose and drapey, not fitted. I really like the way it fits and how soft it is. Color is really pretty as well. So far it's keeping shape well and has been a great layering piece. Also, as someone who makes clothes, this shirt is well made.

I ordered two the rain and blue jay. They feel really good. The quality of the cotton is elevated from what a normal cotton shirt is. I'm tall and they are a nice generous length.

My only feedback is I wish toad would make some in a version that is a little more flattering, less boxy and maybe offer it in a v neck or boat neck or slight scoop neck for a more feminine look. But I got them because the colors are bright and cheery which is hard to find in a long sleeve t shirt, because most companies only make dark dreary colors to go with winter.